Scenario Das Hexenkessel

Special rules 'to the last bullet' say about defenders but later say about Germans. So, when Germans are defending they can add D3 to BR and only Germans? I want use this scenario to barbarossa period but defending will be soviets.

So?

Give the Russians 'To the Last Bullet'...

So, any nation is defending i can add d3 to BR. I dont know why rules say about Germans.

Because the scenario is from Fall of the Reich and a German Defence only specific scenario in that book.

If you want to use it with others and give them the BR boost... go for it.

But what with objectives? If i roll 1 and first must be in defending zone - defender will occupy all objectives and attacker will lose before game begin. I think in this scenario should be rule like this in scenario Defence Line - "The Defender cannot claim an all objectives secured victory".

Someone played this scenario (except Piers) ? How with balance? I have doubts because defender have all units at beginning and could easily crushed weak attacker forces.

Well that's me told!

Right, DIe Hexenkessel....

To the last Bullet applies to the Defender. If you use this scenario for any other period/nation , the Defender gets the extra D3 BR. No need to give that any hard thoughts, it just is.

As Warwick and Piers noted in the past, for scenario's like this there is no automatic victory for the defender if there is just a single objective. Which makes perfect sense if you spare a thought, there is no need for a special rule.

Yes, it is a fun and deadly scenario. I'm not sure what rulessystems you played before, but this is a serious tactical challenge. You have no idea where the enemy will focus their forces due to the random selection of the entry point for the reserves, while you have to put yours in the proverbial wagon wheel to cover all sides. Yes, even the side where there is no random entry point. The enemy does not sit still.

Someone played this scenario (except Piers) ? How with balance? I have doubts because defender have all units at beginning and could easily crushed weak attacker forces.

<sigh> Play the scenario. There is no such thing as easily crushing stuff in Battlegroup unless the enemy is doing stupid things. Your defenders will have a hard time as they are bunched up so a prime target for artillery, for instance. If you survive you can assume your forces meet up with you so you can withdraw. If you lose, you will have held up the enemy for a bit so the rest of your army can regroup, and you get a nice shiney medal on your grave or one free trip to a POW camp.

Also, telling the man who has played and tested more scenarios than anyone I know not to comment is.... for real?

No offense Bohun, but maybe these aren't the rules for you? I get giving feedback, but you seem to question any answer the author/creator's give you? Just saying.......